Dear Fletch, Thank you for your thoughtful and eloquent post. I, too, object to the idea of theater awards and would not participate in same.
When the late Journal/Sentinel critic Jay Joslyn proposed such awards at his farewell party, I spoke out against them, even though it was hardly an appropriate time to contradict the wishes of the honoree. Whether you work Equity or non-Equity, at a large theater or a small, there is no way to compare any performances in any category: apples and oranges every time, and theater is not a competitive sport. Please feel free to cross post my response.
Rose Pickering
Milwaukee Rep